Deck · Before and after · Theme
The same lesson: GPT-5.6 Luna versus Muse Spark 1.3
Each model got the exact prompt Luna received in run cfa-v3-after5: the plan, the compiled fixtures, the voice rules, the source packet. Read the opening and the trap side by side, then open the full draft. Scores are the Luna reviewer's rubric on that draft; latency is one call at default reasoning settings.
| Writer | Completed | Mean latency | Mean cost | Rubric /26 | Voice /2 | Words |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| GPT-5.6 Luna (today) | 3/3 | 256 s | $0.054 | 23.3 | 1.67 | 1852 |
| Muse Spark 1.3 | 3/3 | 213 s | $0.004 | 23.0 | 1.67 | 1204 |
Writing: opening and trap, side by side
The opening is what a candidate reads after the On the exam line. The trap is the Common error section (chapters) or how the exam tests the module (overviews).
Pricing and valuing equity forwards and futures
Bond price from yield-to-maturity between coupon dates
Code of Ethics and Standards of Professional Conduct
Planning: the brief each model wrote for the writer
Same planner prompt; a plan is valid when it passes the pipeline's plan validator (LOS coverage, fixtures, visual and practice rules).
Pricing and valuing equity forwards and futures
describe how equity forwards and futures are priced, and calculate and interpret their no-arbitrage value
Candidates often treat the quoted delivery price as the fair price, forget to subtract the present value of dividends, or choose the hedge direction before comparing the quote with the no-arbitrage price; the tell is a quote above fair value that is paired with a long-forward hedge instead of a short-forward-and-buy-underlying strategy.
The question gives the equity index spot level, present value of distributions, financing rate, maturity, contract multiplier and a forward or futures quote, then asks for the fair price or current value and the payoff, profit or arbitrage direction in an MCQ or item-set ledger.
Describe how equity forwards and futures are priced and calculate and interpret their no-arbitrage value for long and short positions.
Candidate reverses long/short value to F0-Ft for long or adds PV dividend to spot because owning the stock feels like adding income; tell is position ledger: long gains when Ft rises and known cash dividends lower F0 so subtract PV div from spot.
Vignette hands spot, dividend amount and timing, risk-free rate and maturity or seasoned agreed price, then asks for no-arbitrage forward price or market value to long/short in MCQ and item-set form.
Bond price from yield-to-maturity between coupon dates
Calculate a bond’s price given a yield-to-maturity on or between coupon dates.
Candidates often report the discounted amount as the clean price because it feels like the quoted bond price; the tell is settlement between coupon dates and an accrued-interest instruction, so add accrued interest for dirty/full price and subtract it for clean/flat price.
The question gives face value, coupon rate, payment frequency, settlement timing, and YTM, then asks for the bond’s clean or dirty price in a numerical calculation or asks the candidate to order the valuation steps.
Calculate a bond's price given a yield-to-maturity on or between coupon dates, reporting clean versus full price with settlement and compounding stated.
Candidate quotes full price when asked for clean (or adds accrued twice) because dirty feels like the complete value; tell is quoted/clean/flat vs full/dirty/invoice wording plus a settlement date between coupons.
Stem hands semiannual coupon, face, YTM, periods per year and days since last coupon and asks for full vs clean price in MCQ/fill-blank form requiring periodic yield and t/T adjustment.
Code of Ethics and Standards of Professional Conduct
Describe how CFA Institute investigates and reviews alleged violations, and explain the ethical responsibilities established by the Code and each subsection of the Standards.
Trap: treating the Code as an aspirational checklist; the tell is an answer that does not identify the named actor, exact Standard, affected party, and type of obligation.
Describe the structure of the CFA Institute Professional Conduct Program and disciplinary review process and explain the ethical responsibilities required by the Code and each Standard subsection.
Writer brief: candidates use ordinary moral intuition to judge ethics; feels right because facts seem unfair, giveaway is answer names no exact Standard/subsection and affected party.
Reviewing: the same Luna draft judged by each model
Each model reviewed Luna's traced draft with the reviewer prompt. Compare what they quoted for voice and which issues they raised first.
Pricing and valuing equity forwards and futures
Before reading on, recompute the long-value numerator with the changed $K$ and check its sign.
- major The lesson conflates the value of the investor's existing long forward with a separate cash-and-carry arbitrage portfolio. Shorting a rich forward and buying the underlying is the arbitrage trade for a new short position
- major The displayed results require retaining the unrounded fair price, but the lesson does not say to do so. The changed condition is also not exactly fair: the unrounded fair price is approximately 4,016.8047, so a quote of
- minor The keystrokes do not establish that P/Y is set to 1, which is required for the displayed annual-compounding calculation if the calculator has been left in another payment-frequency setting.
An equity forward lets you lock today the price for equity exposure delivered at a future date.
- none
Bond price from yield-to-maturity between coupon dates
The annual YTM is converted to the coupon-period basis before discounting.
- minor The calculator guidance explains the sign convention but does not provide keystrokes or displays that reproduce the central price. A candidate cannot verify the example directly from the lesson.
- minor The division of annual YTM by payments per year implicitly assumes a nominal annual YTM compounded m times per year, but the yield convention and compounding convention are not stated explicitly. The example also uses a
- minor These sentences restate the three immediately preceding table rows almost verbatim, reducing compression without adding a new example or interpretation.
Before reading on, convert the after-case annual YTM to its periodic YTM yourself.
- minor LOS 1 asks only to calculate price on or between coupon dates. The main body adds a full approximate modified-duration calculation and price-YTM sensitivity discussion outside the labelled Go deeper, which belongs to rel
- minor Quantitative L1 unit with keyable calculations provides only generic prose, no keystrokes with displays that reproduce the 1,025.12 / 1,017.62 or 1,000.00 examples.
- minor Go deeper table already defines Modified duration / Effective duration / Spread / Parallel curve move; the following paragraph restates the same three definitions almost verbatim with no new teaching.
Code of Ethics and Standards of Professional Conduct
The affected professional activity determines which requirements must be compared.
- minor The lesson reproduces both LOS statements in a table, but the organizing heading is generic rather than an LOS-verbatim heading. The overview also adds exam-answer and prevention guidance without labeling it as supplemen
- minor The lesson is strong as a rule locator but often presents the subsections as a catalogue before explaining the mechanism, intuition, or trigger that makes one provision control over another.
- major The process presentation reads as a mandatory linear path from Statement of Allegations to Statement of Charges to hearing. Under the cited Rules, a Statement of Allegations is discretionary; a matter may proceed differe
Ethics can decide whether a Level III answer earns credit because the exam gives you a fact pattern and expects a provision-based decision.
- major Lesson provides two distinct scenarios but no concrete changed-condition perturbation that reuses one scenario with one input changed plus direction and reason. Second example is a different fact pattern, not a faded per